Language Selection

Retrouvez votre bien-être dans ces temps dure sur Terre , Essayez le MedBed Quantique!
Cliquez ici pour réserver votre séance

Famille et pour toute la Famille avec Le Medbed Quantique® Orgo-Life® une technologie du Canada

Advertising by Adpathway

         

 Advertising by Adpathway

No charges but not the end: What comes next for the players at the centre of the Pullman Hotel scandal

3 hour_ago 95

         

NE LAISSER PAS LE 5G DETRUIRE VOTRE ADN Protéger toute votre famille avec les appareils Quantiques Orgo-Life®

  Publicité par Adpathway

The decision by Victoria Police not to charge four AFL players over the Pullman Hotel incident might appear to bring a difficult episode to an end. Legally, however, it may simply move it into a different phase.

Police concluded their investigation without laying charges. That does not determine precisely what occurred, nor necessarily end the prospect of civil proceedings or further AFL action.

WATCH THE VIDEO ABOVE: Heeney speaks to 7NEWS after police drop investigation

Know the news with the 7NEWS app: Download today Arrow

Indeed, the AFL has expressly reserved the right to investigate if further relevant information comes to light.

Criminal proceedings, civil litigation and sporting disciplinary processes are separate, with different purposes, rules and standards.

No charges does not mean a factual finding

A decision not to prosecute means police have concluded there is not a sufficient basis to lay criminal charges (against Isaac Heeney, Chad Warner, Nick Blakey and James Jordon). It is not the same as acquittal after trial. Nor is it a judicial finding about precisely what occurred.

That distinction matters if civil proceedings follow.

Criminal guilt must be proved beyond reasonable doubt. Civil cases use the lower balance of probabilities standard, meaning something is more likely than not to have happened. The standard stays the same for serious allegations, but stronger evidence may be needed.

Court proceedings and witness evidence might reveal new material. But not all of that material would necessarily become publicly available or be accessible to the AFL.

Be the first to know:

A civil claim may never reach trial

Civil disputes commonly settle without a court determining what happened.

A settlement would not ordinarily establish what occurred unless it incorporated admissions or agreed facts. Payment of compensation, particularly under an agreement expressly denying liability, should not by itself be treated as proof that the allegations were established.

If credible new information emerged during civil proceedings and lawfully reached the AFL, it might support a further investigation.

Equally, a confidential settlement could end the dispute without the AFL obtaining additional evidence. Settlement negotiations may also be confidential or legally protected from later use as evidence.

The dividing line is not whether a claim is made or settled, but whether materially new and reliable information emerges.

The AFL is not a criminal court

The AFL and its clubs do not necessarily have to establish that a player committed a criminal offence before taking disciplinary action.

That is reflected in the action already taken. The Swans stood down five players for the remainder of the season, including finals, because their conduct was said to have fallen short of expected behavioural standards. That action was expressly treated as separate from the criminal investigation.

AFL players are subject to a regulatory and contractual framework extending beyond the criminal law. AFL rules include provisions dealing with conduct considered unbecoming or prejudicial to the interests of the league.

That gives the AFL significant authority, but not an unlimited power to act simply because allegations remain unresolved or controversial.

The AFL Rules, collective bargaining arrangements, policies and player contracts would determine the process and players’ rights. A defensible process would ordinarily require notice of any new allegations and a meaningful opportunity to respond.

Could the players be sanctioned again?

The earlier sanctions do not necessarily bar further action. Much depends on what they addressed, the AFL’s powers and whether genuinely new conduct or evidence emerges.

Further sanctions for substantially the same conduct would raise questions about the relationship between the two actions and whether new information justified another penalty.

The players could contest the evidence and applicable provisions, rely on the earlier sanctions, and invoke available review or grievance protections.

Blakey’s move to North Melbourne adds a complication. Any new action would need to distinguish between the powers of his former club, current club and the AFL’s competition-wide jurisdiction.

What happens next?

The police decision does not retrospectively invalidate Sydney’s sanctions. Those sanctions were imposed by reference to behavioural expectations rather than the laying or proof of criminal charges.

Nor does the possibility of a civil claim give the AFL an automatic basis for further punishment. A claim could proceed to judgment, reveal new evidence, settle confidentially or never proceed at all. A settlement would not itself establish wrongdoing.

If credible and materially new information emerges, whether through civil proceedings or another source, the AFL may have grounds to investigate further. Any resulting sanction would still need to be authorised under the applicable framework and imposed through a defensible process.

Without such information, additional sanctions would be substantially more difficult to justify.

The police investigation is over. Whether the broader legal and disciplinary story is over will depend on what emerges next.

read-entire-article

         

        

Une nouvelle Vibration dans le Monde entier avec les Franchise Medbed Quantique®!  

Protéger toute votre famille avec la technologie Orgo-Life®

  Advertising by Adpathway